Which is More Reliable: Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander Face-Off


The Toyota Highlander generally has a slight edge in reliability over the Honda Pilot. Both SUVs are known for their durability, but the Highlander often ranks higher in reliability ratings.


Choosing between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander can be a tough decision for any SUV enthusiast or family-conscious buyer. Both vehicles come with a reputation for longevity and robust performance, making them leaders in the midsize SUV category. The Highlander, with its consistent top marks in reliability from various reputable automotive sources, often takes the lead in this tight race.


Drivers gravitate towards the Honda Pilot for its spacious interior and comfortable ride, while the Toyota Highlander garners attention for its longevity and lower maintenance costs. Safety features, resale value, and customer satisfaction scores play crucial roles in swaying potential buyers looking for a dependable vehicle that stands the test of time.

Which is More Reliable: Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander Face-Off

Credit: www.ryanhonda.net


 Honda Pilot Vs Toyota Highlander Rivalry


The Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander rivalry is a tale as old as time for those in pursuit of the perfect family SUV. These two titans have competed for the hearts and driveways of families for years. They promise space, reliability, and features that aim to make every journey a pleasure. In this fierce competition, choosing between them is more than a mere preference—it’s about finding a trusted companion for all of life’s adventures.


The Battle Of The Family Suvs


When it comes to conquering family travels, both the Honda Pilot and the Toyota Highlander stand tall as popular choices. They offer ample room, comfort, and advanced safety features. As the needs of today’s families evolve, these SUVs have also adapted, packing more technology and efficiency into their sturdy frames. This ongoing battle has only intensified, as both seek to outperform the other in delivering exceptional driving experiences.


Pilot And Highlander: Market Position


The Pilot and Highlander each boast unique strengths, aiming to capture significant market share. The Honda Pilot, known for its smooth ride and spacious interior, appeals to those who value comfort and cargo space.


On the other side, the Toyota Highlander garners attention with its reputation for durability and resale value. Both aim to be the top pick in a crowded segment, continually pushing the envelope in performance, safety, and innovation. With a loyal fanbase behind each model, they hold esteemed positions in the family SUV market.

Feature Honda Pilot Toyota Highlander
Seating Capacity Up to 8 Up to 8
Cargo Space Generous Ample
Fuel Efficiency Competitive Optimized
Resale Value Strong Excellent
Safety Features Advanced



Under The Hood: Performance Comparison


Let’s dive into what makes these SUVs tick. We’re comparing the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander. We’ll see who wins in power and fuel thriftiness.

Engine Specs And Horsepower


Both SUVs have impressive engines, but they differ.

Vehicle Engine Horsepower
Honda Pilot 3.5L V6 280 HP
Toyota Highlander 3.5L V6 295 HP

Honda’s Pilot offers solid power. The Highlander steps up with a bit more punch.


Fuel Efficiency And Economy


Saving fuel is key. Let’s see which SUV does it better.

  • Pilot: Up to 20 city/27 highway MPG
  • Highlander: Up to 21 city/29 highway MPG

The Highlander edges ahead in fuel savings, making every mile count.


Design And Comfort: Interior Showdown


When you step into either the Honda Pilot or Toyota Highlander, you’re entering a realm where design touches every corner and comfort embraces every seat. It’s a contest of which family vehicle feels more like home.


Cabin Space And Seating


The Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander offer generous cabin space, but there’s only one champion of comfort.

Feature Honda Pilot Toyota Highlander
Seating Capacity 8 people 8 people
Legroom (1st/2nd/3rd row) 40.9″/38.4″/31.9″ 40.4″/41.0″/27.7″
Cargo Space 18.5 to 83.9 cu ft 16.0 to 84.3 cu ft

The Pilot provides ample room for all passengers. It brings a little more space in the third row, making it a win for bigger families or those with tall teens. Both vehicles boast flexible seating layouts and impressive cargo capacities when you need to haul more than people.


Interior Features And Amenities


On the tech side, both SUVs pack a punch with their own sets of interior features and amenities.

  • Dual-Zone Climate Control: Standard in both for comfort across all seasons.
  • Infotainment System: Both come with touchscreen displays and smartphone integration.
  • Power-Adjustable Seats: Customize your driving position easily.

In the amenities department, the Pilot often edges ahead with more user-friendly controls and an available rear entertainment system that’s a hit with kids. The Highlander’s trim levels include upscale options with leather and premium materials that scream luxury.


In this head-to-head, it’s clear both the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander put a strong emphasis on keeping their cabins cozy and well-equipped. The choice comes down to personal preference—do you prioritize easy-to-use entertainment or a touch of luxury to your ride?


Technology And Entertainment


Technology and Entertainment play massive roles in deciding on a family SUV. The Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander offer advanced tech that keeps everyone on board entertained and connected. From streaming music to following maps, technology makes driving better. Explore the tech features of both the Honda Pilot and the Toyota Highlander to understand which SUV scores higher on the tech-savvy scale.


Infotainment Systems


The center of in-car entertainment and information is the infotainment system. Honda’s Pilot boasts an 8-inch Display Audio touch-screen. It has physical buttons and knobs for easier control. The system supports both Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. The Highlander’s system also features an 8-inch touch-screen. However, top trims offer a larger 12.3-inch display, a unique feature giving Toyota an edge.


Connectivity And Navigation Tools


Staying connected on the road is important. Both SUVs offer a suite of services to keep you linked to the outside world. The Pilot packs multiple USB ports and Honda’s Satellite-Linked Navigation System™. This system uses voice recognition and provides real-time traffic updates.


Toyota’s Highlander steps up with its Driver Easy Speak feature. It amplifies the driver’s voice through rear speakers. This is handy when communicating with passengers in the back. Additionally, Highlander offers a Wi-Fi Connect feature, allowing up to five devices to use the in-vehicle network.


  • Honda Pilot:
    • 8-inch Display Audio touch-screen
    • Several USB ports
    • Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
    • Honda Satellite-Linked Navigation System™


  • Toyota Highlander:
    • 8-inch or 12.3-inch touch-screen display
    • Driver Easy Speak feature
    • Wi-Fi Connect for up to 5 devices
    • Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
  Honda Pilot Toyota Highlander
Touch-Screen Size 8-inch 8-inch standard, 12.3-inch available
Navigation Standard Satellite-linked Available Integrated Navigation
Unique Features Multi-angle rearview camera Driver Easy Speak & Wi-Fi Connect


Safety First: Comparing Safety Features


When choosing between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, safety features place high on the list. Both SUVs promise to keep passengers safe. This comparison dives into their active and passive safety highlights and crash test scores. Knowing these details can help make an informed decision for family safety on the roads.


Active And Passive Safety Highlights


Starting with the Honda Pilot, the SUV offers numerous active safety features:
  • Honda Sensing®: A suite of advanced driver aids.
  • Collision Mitigation Braking System™: Helps prevent front crashes.
  • Road Departure Mitigation System™: Keeps you on the road.
Passive features include:
  • Advanced airbag systems: Protects in a collision.
  • ACE™ body structure: Enhances occupant protection.
Looking at the Toyota Highlander, it matches up with:
  • Toyota Safety Sense™: Packed with safety tech.
  • Pre-Collision System with Pedestrian Detection: Avoids accidents.
  • Lane Departure Alert with Steering Assist: Alerts and corrects lane drifting.
Passive safety includes:
  • Eight airbags: Surrounds passengers with safety.
  • Star Safety System™: Stability and traction control.


Crash Test Scores And Ratings


The Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander have both undergone rigorous testing by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS).
Latest NHTSA and IIHS Scores
Vehicle NHTSA Overall Rating IIHS Top Safety Pick
Honda Pilot 5 Stars Yes
Toyota Highlander 5 Stars Yes

Both vehicles achieved the highest five-star overall safety rating from NHTSA. They also earned IIHS Top Safety Pick recognitions. These ratings reflect their strong performance in crashworthiness and crash avoidance technologies.

Which is More Reliable: Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander Face-Off

Credit: www.carmax.com


Ride Quality And Handling


When deciding between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, ride quality and handling are key. Both SUVs aim to deliver a smooth ride and sharp handling. Let’s explore how the Pilot and Highlander stand out.


Suspension And Ride Comfort


The Honda Pilot features a fully independent suspension. This setup offers a comfortable and controlled ride. The Toyota Highlander, equally equipped, provides a similarly smooth experience over bumps. Both aim to keep passengers relaxed on various terrains.

  • Honda’s suspension absorbs road imperfections well.
  • Toyota’s tuning prioritizes comfort, ideal for long drives.


Handling Dynamics


Handling is where the two diverge. The Pilot is recognized for its agility. It takes corners with confidence and minimal body roll. The Highlander, on the other hand, maintains poise. It’s stable but less sporty than the Pilot. Both models offer different handling personalities that are reliable in their own right.

Aspect Honda Pilot Toyota Highlander
Cornering Confident Stable
Body Roll Minimal Controlled
Suspension Independent Independent


Price Tag: Value For Money


When choosing between the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, cost is key. Both offer great features, but which gives you the ‘bang for your buck’? Smart buyers look at prices and long-term costs. We’ll dive into both, helping you make a well-informed decision.


Base Price And Trims


The base model sets the stage for pricing. Let’s compare.

Vehicle Base Model Starting Price
Honda Pilot $32,550
Toyota Highlander $35,085

Higher trims add more features. Toyota Highlander has XLE, Limited and Platinum. Honda Pilot offers EX, EX-L, Touring, and Elite. Each step up means more tech and comfort, but also more dollars.


Long-term Ownership Costs


It’s not just about today’s price tag. Think of tomorrow too. Long-term costs cover maintenance, repairs, fuel, insurance, and depreciation. Here’s a quick look:

  • Honda Pilot
    • Lower average repair costs
    • Good fuel efficiency for size
    • Resale value stays strong
  • Toyota Highlander
    • Known for durability
    • Slightly better fuel economy
    • Keeps value over the years

Both cars promise reliability. They keep running costs in check. Insurance tends to be similar. The Honda Pilot edges out slightly in overall long-term value. This includes when it’s time to sell.


Resale Value And Reliability


When considering a long-term investment in a vehicle, two key aspects dominate the decision-making landscape: resale value and reliability. Both the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander have stellar reputations.


Choosing between them often boils down to these factors. The resale value reflects how well the car holds its worth over time. Reliability predicts the likelihood of the vehicle running smoothly with minimal issues.


Depreciation Trends


Depreciation trends provide a window into the future value of a car. For the Honda Pilot and Toyota Highlander, these trends are telling. A car that depreciates less saves money in the long-run. Data reveals both models depreciate slower than the average SUV. But subtle differences exist.

  • Honda Pilot holds approximately 60% of its value after three years.
  • Toyota Highlander retains slightly more, around 65%, in the same period.


Historical Reliability Records


Historical reliability records are invaluable. They show how well a car performs over years. Both the Pilot and Highlander have strong track records.

Vehicle Reliability Rating
Honda Pilot 4/5 (Above Average)
Toyota Highlander 4.5/5 (Excellent)

The Pilot and Highlander often exceed the 100,000-mile mark, often reaching 200,000 with proper care. This level of endurance reflects their reliability. Toyota’s slight edge in reliability ratings mirrors its higher resale values. Proper maintenance can enhance these figures further, building trust in these models’ consistency and endurance.


Brand Loyalty Factors


Brand loyalty doesn’t happen overnight. It grows from consistency and customer care. Here’s what keeps drivers coming back.

Honda Pilot Toyota Highlander
Long-term reliability Strong resale value
Flexible seating options Diverse safety features

Honda’s loyalty springs from a legacy of dependability. Toyota earns trust through innovation in safety. Both serve as key factors why drivers stick to these brands.


Final Thoughts On Making A Decision

Factor Honda Pilot Toyota Highlander
Space More Less
Resale Value Good Better
Reliability High Very High

Your final choice rests on what ranks higher on your priority list. For unrivaled space and comfort, the Honda Pilot is a strong contender. If you lean towards investment value and dependability, the Toyota Highlander won’t disappoint. Trust the facts, your budget, and your gut to steer you to the perfect SUV.

Which is More Reliable: Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander Face-Off

Credit: driving.ca

Leave a Comment